The search has once again begun to name the Best Historic Small Town in America, and just like last year we have two Michigan finalists hoping for the top spot. One is no stranger to this poll, as it continually draws the attention of 10best.com for being a car-free island full of historic buildings, while the other has finished in the top five of this poll two years in a row and is known for its maritime and lumber history. Today we will take a look at why Mackinac Island and Ludington are worthy of this honor, and share how you can vote for them to be named the Best Historic Small Town in America.

Mackinac Island has been a finalist in this contest numerous times over the last decade, with a second place finish in 2019. USA Today/10best say: “Long before European arrival, it was home to the Anishinaabek People with the French arriving in the 1600s, followed by British and later American stewardship, each leaving a lasting imprint. Now a scenic, car-free destination in northern Michigan, the island preserves its heritage through exceptional historic sites.”

You can dive into history on Mackinac Island by touring Fort Mackinac or Fort Holmes, exploring Biddle House or the American Fur Company Store, or staying at the legendary Grand Hotel. Several museums on the island are full of historical artifacts and information, and historical markers cover the island to help tell its story. You can cast a vote for Mackinac Island once per day now through March 30th, it is also one of four Michigan finalists in the search for the Best Small Town in the Midwest.

Ludington won this contest two years ago, then had to settle for a fourth place finish in 2025. USA Today/10best says that this Lake Michigan town “built its economy on the lumber industry and has continued to thrive as a shipping port, both by water and by train. Today, visitors come to explore Ludington’s small-town charm, enjoy its waterfront location, and shop at its many specialty shops and art galleries.” The Historic White Pine Village and the Port of Ludington Maritime Museum are top draws for visitors, as is the S.S. Badger, the last remaining coal-powered steamship in the country. The Badger makes daily trips carrying passengers and vehicles between Ludington and Manitowoc, Wisconsin during the summer months.

Those looking to dive deeper into Ludington history can travel the Lumber Heritage Trail, the Mason County Sculpture Trail, the Maritime Heritage Trail, the Agricultural Trail, the Music Heritage Trail, and even the Barn Quilt Trail. At Ludington State Park you can visit the Big Sable Point Lighthouse and explore miles of trails. The Ludington North Breakwater Light is also open for tours in the summer months. You can vote for Ludington once per day now through March 30th.